First-Time Watch - Revisiting the Romulans in Star Trek: The Original Series and The Next Generation
The Romulans are one of the most recognizable adversaries in the Star Trek universe.
But how did they become that way?
As we continue our TBG Supplemental series, I'm revisiting several important episodes to explore how Star Trek introduced and developed some of its most significant characters, civilizations, and storylines.
And we're beginning with the Romulans.
For this first installment of a two-part discussion, we're returning to the original introduction of the Romulans in The Original Series, their subsequent appearance in The Enterprise Incident, and their eventual return in The Next Generation after more than fifty years without direct contact with the Federation.
After rewatching each episode, I'll share some fresh thoughts and revisit portions of our original To Baldly Go discussions.
It's an opportunity to explore the development of Star Trek's lore while also examining how my own perspective has changed after watching five seasons of The Next Generation.
This week, we get:
One of the finest episodes of The Original Series
A surprisingly disappointing return for a formidable adversary
The Romulans reemerging after more than fifty years
A look at how context changes our appreciation of an episode
Revisiting our original podcast discussions with a new perspective
We covered:
Balance of Terror (TOS S1E14) - Originally TBG 007
The Enterprise Incident (TOS S3E02) - Originally TBG 022
The Neutral Zone (TNG S1E25) - Originally TBG 040
Balance of Terror
Original Rating: 8 | Rewatch Rating: 9
What an extraordinary episode.
Balance of Terror introduces the Romulans by establishing a conflict that already has more than a century of history behind it.
A devastating war, a carefully negotiated treaty, and a Neutral Zone separating two powerful civilizations provide the foundation for a remarkably tense confrontation.
When Federation outposts along the Neutral Zone begin disappearing, Captain Kirk must determine how to respond without inadvertently triggering another war.
What follows is a brilliant battle of strategy between Kirk and the Romulan commander.
Watching this episode again, I was struck by just how effective its storytelling is.
The writing, acting, tension, and pacing are superb. Every decision matters, and the consequences feel genuinely significant.
Perhaps most importantly, both Kirk and the Romulan commander are portrayed as exceptional leaders.
They're enemies, but they recognize one another's abilities and responsibilities.
Their conflict isn't simply a matter of good versus evil. It's a confrontation between two capable commanders bound by duty.
The episode's tragic conclusion reinforces that theme, reminding us that even a successful military engagement can carry an enormous human cost.
Balance of Terror accomplishes something else particularly impressive: it establishes the Romulans as a potentially enormous threat without requiring an extended storyline.
From their very first appearance, we understand that there's an entire civilization beyond the Federation's borders with its own history, military capabilities, and political motivations.
It's remarkable worldbuilding.
And after watching so much more Star Trek, I find myself appreciating the episode even more than I did initially.
This time, I gave it a 9.
Things I'm revisiting:
The incredible tension and storytelling of Balance of Terror
The strategic battle between Kirk and the Romulan commander
How the episode establishes more than a century of history
Kirk's leadership and the mutual respect between enemies
Duty, sacrifice, and the tragic conclusion
Why this might be quintessential Star Trek
Revisiting our original discussion from TBG 007
The Enterprise Incident
Original Rating: 7 | Rewatch Rating: 6
Our second episode offers a very different experience.
In The Enterprise Incident, Kirk and Spock undertake a secret Federation mission to steal Romulan cloaking technology.
Their plan involves elaborate deception, apparent betrayal, and a series of calculated risks as they maneuver the Enterprise into Romulan territory.
As an espionage adventure, there's quite a bit to enjoy.
Kirk and Spock's willingness to deceive nearly everyone involved, including their own crew, makes for an entertaining conspiracy.
The eventual revelation that they've been operating under Federation orders is particularly effective.
But there's one significant problem.
The Romulans themselves don't seem especially important to the story.
In Balance of Terror, the Romulans were formidable adversaries. Their history with the Federation, military capabilities, and strategic thinking were essential to the episode.
Here, they seem surprisingly easy to manipulate.
Their relationship to the Vulcans adds some interesting context, but otherwise, the story could largely be told with another alien civilization filling the same role.
That left me feeling somewhat disappointed.
The first time I watched The Enterprise Incident, I gave it a 7 and seriously considered an 8.
This time, I gave it a 6.
Part of that difference may simply be the circumstances of each viewing.
Originally, I watched it immediately after Spock's Brain, which I downgraded during our discussion from a 5 to a 4.
On this rewatch, I watched it shortly after Balance of Terror, which I had just upgraded to a 9.
That contrast was difficult to ignore.
And it raises an interesting question about how we evaluate television episodes.
Does an episode's quality change depending on what we're expecting from it?
As a Kirk and Spock espionage adventure, The Enterprise Incident has plenty to offer.
But as an important installment in the development of the Romulans, I find it considerably less satisfying.
Things I'm revisiting:
The Federation's secret mission to steal cloaking technology
Kirk and Spock's elaborate deception
The relationship between Romulans and Vulcans
The difference between an espionage adventure and a meaningful Romulan story
Why the Romulans seem less threatening than before
How viewing context may have affected my rating
Revisiting our original discussion from TBG 022
The Neutral Zone
Original Rating: 5 | Rewatch Rating: 5
For our final episode, we're jumping forward to the first-season finale of Star Trek: The Next Generation.
And within the fictional universe, more than fifty-three years have passed since the Federation last had direct contact with the Romulans.
The Enterprise is investigating the disappearance of Federation outposts along the Neutral Zone when it encounters evidence that the Romulans may be returning.
But the Romulans are investigating a similar mystery.
Their own outposts have been destroyed, raising the possibility that both civilizations may be facing an unknown common enemy.
Unfortunately, The Neutral Zone also includes a separate storyline involving three humans revived after centuries of cryogenic preservation.
And the two stories aren't equally effective.
The revived humans provide opportunities to explore the differences between twentieth-century society and the Federation's more enlightened future.
But I didn't find that portion of the episode particularly compelling.
The Romulan storyline, however, is much stronger.
There's a sense of tension and uncertainty reminiscent of Balance of Terror.
The Federation knows relatively little about the Romulans' current capabilities or intentions, and their unexpected reappearance raises the possibility of renewed conflict.
Counselor Troi also offers a fascinating description of Romulan psychology, portraying them as a civilization capable of extraordinary extremes.
Her observations help provide some context for the differences between their earlier appearances.
It's an interesting attempt to give the Romulans a more developed cultural identity.
I also enjoyed seeing the possibility of something even more dangerous lurking beyond the conflict between the Federation and the Romulans.
The episode suggests that these old enemies may eventually need to confront a threat neither side fully understands.
That's a compelling foundation for future storytelling.
Unfortunately, the episode as a whole still falls somewhat short.
I rated The Neutral Zone a 5 during my original viewing, and that rating hasn't changed.
But if I were evaluating only the Romulan storyline, I might give it a 7.
There's a great deal of potential here.
And even though the overall episode is mediocre, the return of the Romulans feels significant.
Things I'm revisiting:
Returning to the first season of The Next Generation after finishing Season 5
How much TNG's early production resembles The Original Series
The Romulans returning after more than fifty years
The mystery surrounding the destroyed outposts
Counselor Troi's description of Romulan psychology
The contrast between the two storylines
The possibility of a common threat to the Federation and Romulans
Revisiting our original discussion from TBG 040
Final Thoughts
Before beginning this project, one of my first introductions to Star Trek was the 2009 reboot movie.
And that movie's principal villain was Nero, a Romulan.
So I already knew the Romulans were a significant part of the Star Trek universe before I ever started watching The Original Series.
But revisiting these episodes has given me a much greater appreciation for how that role developed.
Balance of Terror is a phenomenal introduction.
It establishes an enemy with a rich history, formidable military capabilities, and the potential to become a recurring threat to the Federation.
But the Romulans don't immediately develop into the adversaries we might expect.
The Enterprise Incident provides an entertaining espionage story without doing much to build upon their original introduction.
And by the time we reach The Neutral Zone, the Romulans have once again become something of a mystery.
Their reappearance, however, restores much of the tension and uncertainty that made Balance of Terror so compelling.
It's fascinating to see Star Trek building its fictional universe in this way.
Not every element develops consistently. Some ideas are introduced and largely abandoned, while others return years later to become increasingly important.
And sometimes, the process of revisiting those ideas reveals just how much the franchise has changed.
That's what I'm hoping to explore throughout these supplemental episodes.
Not just what happened in Star Trek, but how its characters, civilizations, and stories developed into the fictional universe we've come to recognize.
Next Week - The Romulans, Part 2
We're not finished with the Romulans yet!
Next week, we'll continue our exploration with three more episodes from The Next Generation:
The Enemy (TNG S3E07)
The Defector (TNG S3E10)
The Mind's Eye (TNG S4E24)
As The Next Generation develops a more interconnected fictional universe, the Romulans become involved in increasingly complicated political and military conflicts.
We'll revisit these stories, explore how their portrayal has evolved, and consider whether Star Trek begins fulfilling the promise of their original introduction.
And, of course, we'll revisit our original podcast conversations to compare my first reactions with my current perspective.
Join me next Tuesday for TBG Supplemental 003 - The Romulans, Part 2.
Thank you for listening and continuing to join me on this journey.
Never give up. Never surrender!
Where we are on our Trek:
Last week we covered:
Next week we will continue with:
Our regular release-order watch-through returns February 2, 2027:
If you want to see my journey from the very beginning, start here:
Also, be sure to check out Nate's and my other podcast - The In Lap with Aaron and Nate - to listen to us discuss all things Formula 1 on race weekends, wherever you listen to your podcasts.
