In Theory

,

Star Trek TNG S04E25-26 In Theory | Redemption – “Star Trek Pizza” | First Time Reaction – To Baldly Go Podcast (Ep. 066)

,

First-Time Watch – Star Trek: The Next Generation Season 4, Episodes 25-26

We’ve reached the end of Season 4 of Star Trek: The Next Generation!

This week, Data tries his hand at romance in “In Theory,” and Worf finds himself caught between Starfleet and the Klingon Empire as a civil war begins in “Redemption.”

This week, we get:

  • Relationships and programmed behaviors

  • Klingons

We covered:

  • In Theory

  • Redemption

In Theory

Data has been studying humanity for years, but this time he takes on one of the more complicated pieces of the human experience: romantic relationships.

When Jenna D’Sora becomes interested in him, Data decides to give dating a try — complete with a newly created program designed to help him behave like the boyfriend he thinks she wants.

There were pieces of the episode that worked much better for us than others. The A and B stories never really seemed to fit together, and at times we wondered whether we had missed something. But Brent Spiner continues to be incredible, and watching Data systematically try to figure out how humans are supposed to behave remains one of the most interesting parts of the character.

Things we discussed

  • Did I miss something?

  • The A/B stories didn’t really work

  • Brent Spiner is a genius

  • Data figuring out how to be a human

  • Data was somehow less awkward than Geordi

  • Projecting expectations onto somebody else

  • Data’s appreciation of a gift

  • Programs for how to behave

  • Jeff Arcuri and crowd-work standup comedy

  • Meta comments and deconstructing Star Trek

  • Live orchestras for Cirque du Soleil shows in Vegas

Redemption

We close Season 4 by returning to one of the strongest pieces of The Next Generation’s ongoing world building: the Klingons.

Gowron’s claim to leadership of the Klingon Empire leads toward civil war, Picard once again finds himself deeply involved in Klingon politics, and Worf has to decide how far his responsibilities to Starfleet extend when his own family and people are involved.

This one clearly isn’t finished. Rather than wrapping up the season with a self-contained story, “Redemption” feels like another piece being added to a larger narrative — and we’re curious to see where it goes.

Things we discussed

  • Klingon world building

  • Season vs. series

  • Seeing ghosts?

  • Picking up on things late

  • Curious to see where this story goes

  • Pieces that are part of a bigger whole

  • Worf’s conflict of interest

  • Picard as arbiter and kingmaker

Final Thoughts

And just like that, we’ve finished four seasons of Star Trek: The Next Generation.

We spend some time talking about “New Trek” before looking back at where the series stands after Season 4.

It’s still a little hard to believe that we’re this far into The Next Generation — and that Aaron is still loving it this much.

The series has become remarkably consistent. Season 4 was another strong year, although Season 3 still gets a slight edge.